Why It’s So Irresistible
-
Flavor Symphony
Lobster brings succulent richness, while scallops offer a tender, sweet contrast. Coated in garlic-infused butter with a splash of lemon and herbs, they deliver luxurious depth without demanding fancy prep .
Seafood recipes with garlic butter are ubiquituous—and for good reason: it amplifies the natural flavor of seafood in a simple, decadent way . -
Quick yet Elegant
You can whip up this dish in about 25–30 minutes—searing, broiling, garnishing—and it feels restaurant-level indulgent . -
Techniques for Perfection
-
Dry scallops: essential for a golden crust.
-
Watch the heat: overcooking lobster makes it rubbery; scallops should be golden—remove early and let residual heat finish them.
-
High-quality butter and gentle garlic—don’t burn it.
-
🍽️ What Reddit Says
Scallop lovers praise the simplicity:
“I love them pan seared in garlic butter.”
Others weigh in on the comparison:
“Scallops kind of have a sweet and succulent taste… bite for bite I prefer scallops but lobster has more utility.”
While some express a lobster-averse stance, many celebrate the garlic butter experience as the star:
“I literally down the 2nd garlic butter sauce like a shot…”
👍 Verdict: I’m In!
-
Taste: Rich, buttery, sweet meets succulent and aromatic.
-
Ease: Weeknight easy with an elegant finish.
-
Versatility: Works solo or as part of surf‑and‑turf; pairs well with asparagus, pasta, or crusty bread .
🥂 Tip for Ultimate Dish
Pair it with garlic-butter asparagus, lemon risotto, or steamed greens, and don’t forget that crusty bread to soak up every last drop of butter.
🧭 Bottom Line
Yes—I’d eat it enthusiastically. A balanced mix of luxury, simplicity, and signature flavor. Whether for a cozy date night or a personal gourmet treat, garlic butter lobster and scallops check all the boxes.
Have you tried making it? I’d love to hear about your experience or any tasty add-ons you’ve discovered!